Old houses for sale in New York NY | Old Houses USA (2024)

The old houses in New York are a showcase of history and architectural beauty. These homes, which date back to the colonial era, exhibit a range of styles, such as Dutch Colonial, Federal, Victorian, and Greek Revival. Local materials such as stone, brick, and timber were used to construct them, resulting in exceptional craftsmanship and attention to detail. Many old houses still retain original elements like hand-carved moldings, intricate fireplaces, and wide-plank floors.

Featured

1826 village Church in Phoenicia, New York - $399k

Charming village Church for sale in Phoenicia, New York. Built in 1826, unique property including accompanying home, four sizable bedrooms, hidden courtyard, 3563 square feet. $399,000.

1850 historical house in Waterloo, New York - $329k

Timeless historical house for sale in Waterloo, New York. Built in 1850, intricate woodwork, beautiful stained glass, five fireplaces, 5 bedrooms, 4816 square feet. $329,900.

1865 Victorian house in Bethlehem, New York - $395k

Renovated Victorian house for sale in Bethlehem, New York. Built in 1865, several updates, in-ground pool, large barn, walk-up loft, bonus space, 4 bedrooms. $395,000.

The Gingerbread House, 1917 Arts and Crafts style in Brooklyn, New York - $8.7 Million

The Gingerbread House for sale in Brooklyn, New York. Built in 1917, designed by architect James Sarsfield Kennedy, Arts and Crafts style, classic architectural elements, hand carved wainscotting and marble mantels, park-like grounds, 6 bedrooms. $8,750,000.

1867 Second Empire house in Athens, New York - $549k

Exquisite Second Empire house for sale in Athens, New York. Built in 1867, masterful woodworking, ornate mansard roof, embellished fireplaces, breathtaking views, 8 bedrooms, 4379 square feet. $549,000.

1904 Tudor house in Belle Terre, New York - $1.1 Million

Stunning English Tudor house for sale in Belle Terre, New York. Built in 1904, impressive woodwork, cross-paned windows, cozy fireplace, koi pond, two-car garage, 5 bedrooms.

The Shumway House, 1827 Federal style in Essex, New York - $995k

The Shumway House for sale in Essex, New York. Built in 1827, high-quality materials throughout, updated kitchen, 4 bedrooms, 3500 square feet, picturesque views, amazing location. $995,000.

Trimmer House, 1891 Victorian style in Penn Yan, New York - $399k

Trimmer House for sale in Penn Yan, New York. Built in 1819, Victorian style, fabulous dining room, beautiful antique furniture, amazing finishing touches, 6 bedrooms, 3642 square feet. $399,900.

1846 Italianate house in Newport, New York - $874k

Breathtaking Italianate house for sale in Newport, New York. Built in 1846, designed by A.J. Davis, limestone, meticulous restoration, 4 bedrooms, 4437 square feet. $874,900.

1938 English Cottage house in Utica, New York - $449k

Classic English Cottage house for sale in Utica, New York. Built in 1938, a huge great room, chef’s kitchen, 5 bedrooms, 2-car garage, 3195 square feet. $449,900.

1905 Colonial house in Shoreham, New York - $999k

Splendid Colonial house for sale in Shoreham, New York. Built in 1905, crown moldings, French doors, 6 fireplaces, full basem*nt, guest house, private beach access, 6 bedrooms. $999,996.

1925 Tudor house in Bronxville, New York - $6.6 Million

Spectacular Tudor house for sale in Bronxville, New York. Built in 1925 by Lewis Bowman, breathtaking rooms, hand carved fireplace, magical oasis with pool, 6 bedrooms, 7850 square feet. $6,695,000.

1830 Historical house in Rochester, New York - $1.2 Million

Stunning Historical house for sale in Rochester, New York. Built in 1830, renovated in 1910, Arts and Crafts ballroom, exposed beam ceilings, Edwardian front porch, 7512 square feet. $1,200,000.

1899 Queen Anne house in Brooklyn, New York - $2.6 Million

Picturesque Queen Anne house for sale in Brooklyn, New York. Built in 1899, designed by architect Henry A. Stunek, bold entrance with multi-colored stained-glass windows, 7 bedrooms. $2,600,000.

1935 Tudor house in Great Neck, New York - $928k

Delightful brick and stone Tudor house for sale in Great Neck, New York. Built in 1935, stained glass windows, three bedrooms, garage, nice backyard. $928,000.

1900 Victorian house in Mamaroneck, New York - $3.6 Million

Fabulous Victorian house for sale in Mamaroneck, New York. Built in 1900, original architectural details and millwork with modern updates, stone fireplace, private beach. $3,650,000.

1924 Georgian Colonial house in Rochester, New York - $319k

Historic Georgian Colonial house for sale in Rochester, New York. Built in 1924 in the heart of Maplewood, leaded glass windows, dentil molding, in-law suite, 3622 square feet. $319,000.

Amberfields Farm, 1805 Federal style house in Averill Park, New York - $1.3 Million

Amberfields Farm for sale in Averill Park, New York. Built in 1805, Federal style, meticulously restored, 4 bedrooms, mature perennial gardens, 2-car garage. $1,350,000.

Oldwalls, 1918 Arts and Crafts style in Brewster, New York - $2.9 Million

Oldwalls, a rare Arts and Crafts stone building for sale in Brewster, New York. Built in 1918, old forest hardwood, European craftsmanship, breathtaking views, 3817 square feet. $2,999,000.

The Lynfield Mansion, 1871 Colonial style in Millbrook, New York - $1.8 Million

The Lynfield Mansion for sale in Millbrook, New York. Built in 1871, Colonial style, magnificent staircase, original marble fireplaces, 9096 sqft, 23 acres with mature trees, duplex, cottage, and large shed. $1,800,000.

1930 Single-Family house in Gloversville, New York - $219k

Immaculate house for sale in Gloversville, New York. Built in 1930, beautiful woodworking, spacious living room, huge backyard, four bedrooms. $219,900.

The Simon P. Van Patten House, 1760 Colonial style in Glenville, New York - $549k

The Simon P. Van Patten House for sale in Glenville, New York. Built in 1760, Colonial style, meticulously restored, floors in Tamarack wood, geothermal heating/cooling, 4 bedrooms. $549,900.

1810 Colonial house in Schenectady, New York - $579k

Historic Colonial Farmhouse for sale in Schenectady, New York. Built in 1810, completely restored, wide planked hardwood floors, four bedrooms, two-car garage. $579,900.

1880 Center Hall house in Selkirk, New York - $824k

Brick Center Hall house for sale in Selkirk, New York. Built in 1880, wide-plank wood floors, lots of natural light, large back deck and pond, lush gardens. $824,900.

1840 Colonial house in Cazenovia, New York - $1 Million

Breathtaking Colonial house for sale in Cazenovia, New York. Built in 1840, large dining room, 6-gas fireplaces, 8500 square feet, two carriage houses. $1,099,900.

1930 Cape Cod house in Kingston, New York - $1.2 Million

Pristine Cape Cod house for sale in Kingston, New York. Built in 1930, wood-burning fireplace, open concept kitchen, heated pool and patio gazebo, 4276 square feet. $1,295,000.

The Cauterskill Ridge House, 1860 Farmhouse in Catskill, New York - $1.8 Million

The Cauterskill Ridge House for sale in Catskill, New York. Built in 1860, impeccably restored, 18 acres with multiple barns, gardens, and a greenhouse. $1,875,000.

1930 Colonial house in Buffalo, New York - $469k

Remarkable Colonial house for sale in Buffalo, New York. Built in 1930, lots of natural woodwork, wood-burning fireplace, updated kitchen, four bedrooms. $469,000.

1923 Colonial house in Scarsdale, New York - $2.9 Million

Stunning Colonial house for sale in Scarsdale, New York. Built in 1923, large-scale renovation, 5 bedrooms, 4352 square feet, close to schools. $2,995,000.

1865 Victorian house in Cornwall On Hudson, New York - $899k

Splendid Victorian house for sale in Cornwall on Hudson, New York. Built in 1865, beautiful craftsmanship throughout, 5 bedrooms, close to great schools. $899,000.

Old houses for sale in New York NY | Old Houses USA (2024)

FAQs

Where in NY has the cheapest houses? ›

Check out our list of the 10 Most Affordable Places to Live in New York and find your happy place in the Empire State.
  1. Ilion. With the best income to home price ratio in the entire state, Ilion is the most affordable city in New York.
  2. Ogdensburg. ...
  3. Massena. ...
  4. Hornell. ...
  5. Herkimer. ...
  6. Olean. ...
  7. Niagara Falls. ...
  8. Fulton. ...
Jun 10, 2023

Why are houses so cheap in New York State? ›

The property tax in upstate New York is extremely high. That the tax is so high explains why the house prices are low compared with other parts of the country. A home buyer faces four costs: • purchase price; • property tax; • maintenance cost; • utility cost.

How much do New York homes cost? ›

The average New York home value is $460,812, up 6.4% over the past year and goes to pending in around 32 days.

What is NY house value? ›

$746,451. The average New York home value is $746,451, down 1.1% over the past year and goes to pending in around 86 days.

What is the cheapest town to live in New York? ›

7 Cheapest Places to Live in NY
  • Hornell. Cost of Living Compared to National Average. ...
  • Ogdensburg. Cost of Living Compared to National Average. ...
  • Niagara Falls. Cost of Living Compared to National Average. ...
  • Oneida. Cost of Living Compared to National Average. ...
  • Syracuse. ...
  • Buffalo. ...
  • Albany.
Feb 8, 2024

What is the safest place to live in New York? ›

12 of the Safest Places to Live in NYC:
  • Battery Park City, Manhattan.
  • Prospect Heights, Brooklyn.
  • Fresh Meadows, Queens.
  • Morningside Heights, Manhattan.
  • Inwood, Manhattan.
  • Roosevelt Island, Manhattan.
  • Nolita, Manhattan.
  • Bellerose, Queens.
Feb 16, 2024

Is it cheaper to live in NY or NJ? ›

NYC is the most expensive city in America so it should come as no surprise that New Jersey offers a more affordable cost of living. Newark and Jersey City are both considerably cheaper than NYC. The median home price in Manhattan is $965,00 while the median home price in Jersey City is $337,000 and $210,000 in Newark.

Is it a good time to buy a house New York? ›

New York Housing Market Conditions

The current real estate market conditions in New York are becoming favorable for home buyers. Here's how: Lower Mortgage Rates: The interest rates for home loans have decreased to 7.05%, marking a decline from approximately 8% in the preceding year of 2023.

Is it cheaper to live in New Jersey or New York City? ›

Benefits of living in New Jersey

New Jersey is generally more affordable than New York City when it comes to housing, groceries, and other expenses. And this is, of course, the main reason for commuting to work. So, overall living costs are 53.3% higher in NYC than in NJ.

How much is food in New York? ›

The cost of food in New York City is also considerably steeper than most other places in the country. The average monthly NYC grocery bill was about $486 in March, compared with about $348 in the U.S. as a whole. But there are many money-saving options if you long to live in NYC.

How much does it cost to live in New York for one person? ›

The cost of living in New York City is 37% higher than the state average and 78% higher than the US average. The average monthly costs (without rent) are $1,574 for a single person and $5,795.70 for a family of four.

How much do you have to make to live in NYC? ›

To no one's surprise, the Big Apple has the biggest threshold. The research revealed that it takes the most money to live comfortably as a single person in New York City, requiring $66.62 in hourly wages, or an annual salary of $138,570.

Are home prices dropping NY? ›

Recent Trends in NYC's Home Purchase Market

Based on data from StreetEasy, the median sales price for homes that sold in 2023 was $764K, down about 2% from a record high of $782K in 2022 but back up to $785K in early 2024.

How much will my house be worth in 5 years? ›

Based on historical averages of 3.5% of home value growth per year, property prices will rise a total of about 18 to 20% in 5 years. The math is simple: 3.5% a year for 5 years, compounding annually. The key is to do the math as compounding because your home value will continue to build.

Why are houses in NY so expensive? ›

Soaring Construction Costs

Construction costs in NYC are also no joke, contributing to the expensive housing. When it's more expensive to build, real estate developers naturally need to charge more to sell or lease the properties to turn a profit, creating a chain reaction that makes everything more expensive.

Is Upstate NY cheaper than NYC? ›

A variety of factors cause upstate NY to have a lower cost of living, including housing, transportation and taxes. Although New York State on average has a higher cost of living compared to much of the rest of the country, Upstate New York is still more affordable compared to New York City.

What part of New York is affordable? ›

Murray Hill, Manhattan is one of the most affordable neighborhoods in NYC. Situated between the East River and 6th Ave. from 23rd St. to 42nd St., the area is also convenient for college students and professionals who want proximity to Grand Central Station and the New York Public Library.

What is the most affordable county in New York? ›

Stacker compiled a list of counties with the lowest cost of living in New York using 2022 rankings from Niche.
  • #8. Steuben County. ...
  • #7. St. ...
  • #6. Chautauqua County. ...
  • #5. Lewis County. ...
  • #4. Franklin County. ...
  • #3. Chenango County. – Overall Grade: C+ ...
  • #2. Allegany County. – Overall Grade: C+ ...
  • #1. Herkimer County. – Overall Grade: B-
Sep 24, 2023

Is Upstate NY a good place to live? ›

Outdoor activities: There are endless opportunities for outdoor recreation in Upstate New York, including hiking, camping, fishing, skiing, and snowboarding. Affordable housing: The cost of living in Upstate New York is generally lower than in other parts of the country, including New York City.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Delena Feil

Last Updated:

Views: 5735

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (45 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Delena Feil

Birthday: 1998-08-29

Address: 747 Lubowitz Run, Sidmouth, HI 90646-5543

Phone: +99513241752844

Job: Design Supervisor

Hobby: Digital arts, Lacemaking, Air sports, Running, Scouting, Shooting, Puzzles

Introduction: My name is Delena Feil, I am a clean, splendid, calm, fancy, jolly, bright, faithful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.